Each of the three top-flight strikes scored by the forward this season have been away from home.
In summary
Nottingham Forest climb past Spurs into sixteenth place, a three-point cushion above the drop zone.
Igor Jesus nods his side ahead moments before the interval.
The England midfielder adds a second and substitute Taiwo Awoniyi seals the win.
Spurs are only one point above the relegation zone and are yet to win a league game this calendar year.
Nottingham Forest secured a giant leap to safety and sent Tottenham further towards the drop fight with a devastating win in North London.
The Forest striker, their playmaker and a late substitute decided the crucial clash to raise their team three points away from the bottom three.
Forest overtook their opponents into 16th, to leave the hosts a point above the bottom three following West Ham's defeat.
It casts further doubt on the position of Tottenham interim manager Igor Tudor, who has been at the helm for seven games.
Tottenham failed to sign the midfielder in the previous transfer window, a protracted pursuit which saw Forest considering Spurs with legal action.
Move forward later, Gibbs-White's strike may have served to push them closer to the second tier in a pivotal outcome for Forest – the maiden victory in the top flight under head coach Vitor Pereira after he joined in February.
Spurs have now not won in the Premier League dating back to late December, suffering six of their past seven league games and appear to be crumbling during Tudor's stewardship.
The Croatian has lost five of his seven games in charge and Sunday's result may prove the most costly yet.
The home side were on top in the first half but Igor Jesus – who had previously turned the ball onto his own crossbar – headed home the opener in first-half stoppage time.
The Spurs winger struck the woodwork just before halftime as the hosts searched for a quick reply but fell further behind after 62 minutes when the midfielder was left unmarked in the area and his effort from Callum Hudson-Odoi's cutback went through Guglielmo Vicario's hands.
After Spurs substitute Lucas Bergvall sliced a good chance wide, a comeback looked unlikely and Awoniyi added a third with a few minutes left, leaving Spurs with seven games to save their top-flight status.
Tottenham Analysis: Manager Under Fire with Tottenham Receiving Mixed Reactions
Where do this Tottenham side now?
It could not have been incredibly damaging if they had tried and another loss in seven Premier League games pushes them closer to the drop.
The manager's job will now surely be under serious scrutiny just over one month after being appointed as Thomas Frank's successor.
Tudor has earned just a point from his five league matches and suffered a humiliation against Forest – who were without a win in the top division for eight weeks.
Spurs are in disarray and face the prospect of dropping from the top flight for the first occasion in decades.
It could have been scripted. Spurs did start with some purpose amid support from the fans but that evaporated in the second half.
Igor Jesus' goal quietened Tottenham Hotspur Stadium and Gibbs-White's goal was the signal for some fans to head for the exits.
Awoniyi compounded the misery but following only two home league wins this term – against Brighton and Brentford – it is hardly a shock.
Tottenham were cheered on and booed off and their top-division future is increasingly in the balance.
Nottingham Forest Analysis: The Manager's Maiden League Victory in Almost a Year So Crucial for Survival Hopes
Pereira had not won in the Premier League since way back in last April.
He left Wolves in November without a victory and it has taken five attempts to take three top-flight points at the City Ground but it could prove massive for their season.
Battling defeats against Liverpool and Brighton were creditable while a draw at the champions showed the team's ability and grit.
This marked Forest's second three-goal victory against Spurs in the league this season, their first achieved under Sean Dyche in the winter, and it was just as deserved.
Away from home, they weathered the early pressure in the opening phase and rarely looked in trouble after the first goal.
Igor Jesus has netted only a handful in the Premier League this term since a multi-million pound transfer from Botafogo last summer.
Each one has secured his team valuable points, with a narrow victory at Wolves and a 2-0 victory at Brentford. His latest goal was his thirteenth strike of the season, with a number coming in the Europa League.
But none may prove more important as this one as the team gain confidence after their midweek penalty shootout win which earned a Europa League quarter-final with the Portuguese giants.
Now there is a rock solid belief they can avoid relegation from here, with West Ham and Tottenham possibly left to battle for their top-flight lives.
Upcoming Fixtures for Both Sides?
Spurs visit Sunderland in the Premier League on April 12th while Nottingham Forest journey to Portugal for their European first leg on 9 April before they host Villa in the league on the same weekend.